Best QB/WR duo in the NFL.

[BlakeJ]

ESPN 97.5 the ticket in Houston started talking about best QB/WR duo in the NFL. Of course they were being Lonnyish and said Schaub/Johnson "and its not even close".

Who in your opinion is the best. Try to take a non-homer angle. I could easily say Alex Smith/Crabtree but I think without a doubt its...............

1) Manning/Wayne
2) Brady/Moss
3a) Schaub/Johnson
3b) Rivers/Jackson
5) Brady/Welker

Romo/Austin
Brees/Colston
Favre/Rice
Ryan/White
Rogers/Jennings
Palmer/Ochocinco
Flacco/Boldin

are all good ones to

[Matthew 2000 Eagle]

As of right now, I'd have to go with the duo of Manning/Wayne. The Brees/Colston duo is pretty strong as well, right along with the others that are listed.

As for the Romo/Austin duo, I'd like to see them do it again. Granted, these 2 have had a little bit of chemistry for awhile now, due to the fact that they ran scout team offense together before Tony was promoted to being a starter, I'd still like to see them do it again.

The Rivers/Jackson duo is killer but, Jackson will miss a few games. Malcom Floyd will have to step up. I like the Schaub/Johnson duo as well. Brady/Moss and Welker is probably the most dangerous but, we all know that Randy will take plays off. The question with Welker is that, will he be able to regain his '07 form? Some think he will and, I hope he does.

I think they're all good duos though.

[E-Vol-ution]

Since new tandems that haven't played together yet are listed, I'll add whoever/Larry Fitzgerald.:D

[Matthew 2000 Eagle]

Since new tandems that haven't played together yet are listed, I'll add whoever/Larry Fitzgerald.:D

Fitzgerald is something else!:eek: THE best reciever in the league, IMO.

Eli might have something going with Smith and Manningham though.

[E-Vol-ution]

Fitzgerald is something else!:eek: THE best reciever in the league, IMO.

Eli might have something going with Smith and Manningham though.

These two definitely have a strong vibe for each other.:notworthy

[thestud]

Since new tandems that haven't played together yet are listed, I'll add whoever/Larry Fitzgerald.:D

on that note.....Romo/Dez? epic win.

[BlakeJ]

on that note.....Romo/Dez? epic win.

pfffffffffffffffffffffft

You better think Dez/Contract first. :rolleyes:

[thestud]

pfffffffffffffffffffffft

You better think Dez/Contract first. :rolleyes:

http://sports.espn.go.com/dallas/nfl/news/story?id=5402508 :rolleyes:

[Favpack]

on that note.....Romo/Dez? epic win.

Done deal. Dez for $11M - that's what I call a bargain. :notworthy

[JMSFan]

ESPN 97.5 the ticket in Houston started talking about best QB/WR duo in the NFL. Of course they were being Lonnyish and said Schaub/Johnson "and its not even close".

Who in your opinion is the best. Try to take a non-homer angle. I could easily say Alex Smith/Crabtree but I think without a doubt its...............

1) Manning/Wayne
2) Brady/Moss
3a) Schaub/Johnson
3b) Rivers/Jackson
5) Brady/Welker

Romo/Austin
Brees/Colston
Favre/Rice
Ryan/White
Rogers/Jennings
Palmer/Ochocinco
Flacco/Boldin

are all good ones to

IMO it is Schaub/Johnson.
Schaub was the 2009 league leader at the QB position and Johnson lead the league in receiving yards for the second consecutive year.

[BlakeJ]

IMO it is Schaub/Johnson.
Schaub was the 2009 league leader at the QB position and Johnson lead the league in receiving yards for the second consecutive year.

???????????????????????

Schaub in 2009

Yards (1)
Passer Rtg (7)
Comp pctg (4)
TDs (5)
Ints (10) worst

Most importantly

Playoff games - 0


Schaub is good....but he isnt the best. Not even close. Probably not even top 5. I know I'd rather have these guys....

Peyton
Brady
Brees
Rivers
Rodgers
McNabb

I put him in the category with Romo, Roethlisberger, Eli, Flacco, Palmer. Good company.

[JMSFan]

???????????????????????

Schaub in 2009

Yards (1)
Passer Rtg (7)
Comp pctg (4)
TDs (5)
Ints (10) worst

Most importantly

Playoff games - 0


Schaub is good....but he isnt the best. Not even close. Probably not even top 5. I know I'd rather have these guys....

Peyton
Brady
Brees
Rivers
Rodgers
McNabb

I put him in the category with Romo, Roethlisberger, Eli, Flacco, Palmer. Good company.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/statistics/player/_/stat/passing

http://espn.go.com/nfl/statistics/team/_/stat/passing

http://espn.go.com/nfl/statistics/team/_/stat/receiving

Make sure you see who is at the top of each list in the links.

[BlakeJ]

http://espn.go.com/nfl/statistics/player/_/stat/passing

http://espn.go.com/nfl/statistics/team/_/stat/passing

http://espn.go.com/nfl/statistics/team/_/stat/receiving

Make sure you see who is at the top of each list in the links.

Maybe you missed it. I credited Schaub with first in passing yards. He trails Peyton in every other statistical and team category beyond that. Most importantly. Schaub has played in ZERO playoff games....ZERO. Schaub is good, but not Peyton or Brady good...not even close.

[BlakeJ]

Even in a game of statistics where team accolades dont matter (Fantasy Football), Schaub is short...take note of the guys ahead of him. ;)

http://sports.yahoo.com/fantasy/nfl/news?slug=ys-expertpoll-pre10-qb

http://fantasynews.cbssports.com/fantasyfootball/rankings?tag=railMid;railMidContent

http://sports.espn.go.com/fantasy/football/ffl/story?page=NFLDK2K10ranksQB

http://sports.espn.go.com/fantasy/football/ffl/story?page=nfldk2k10qbpreview

Again...statistics dont tell the entire story, but since you were talking statistics...I thought I'd throw that in. :)

[JMSFan]

Maybe you missed it. I credited Schaub with first in passing yards. He trails Peyton in every other statistical and team category beyond that. Most importantly. Schaub has played in ZERO playoff games....ZERO. Schaub is good, but not Peyton or Brady good...not even close.

No argument there, but the thread asked for the best tandem. Last season it was Schaub and Johnson.

[BlakeJ]

No argument there, but the thread asked for the best tandem. Last season it was Schaub and Johnson.


Bzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Wrong answer. :)

Neither statistically nor accomlishment wise were they.

[dada]

Maybe you missed it. I credited Schaub with first in passing yards. He trails Peyton in every other statistical and team category beyond that. Most importantly. Schaub has played in ZERO playoff games....ZERO. Schaub is good, but not Peyton or Brady good...not even close.

It's wasnt a poll that said Best Duo to make the playoffs! We're gonna fight!

[BlakeJ]

It's wasnt a poll that said Best Duo to make the playoffs! We're gonna fight!

Dont do it Dada. Please do not tell me you think Schaub/Dre are the best QB/WR duo in the league.

If the Texans announced today that they traded Schaub/Johnson for Manning/Wayne for one year only....you would be estatic. Not to mention that makes the Texans instant AFC contenders.

[dada]

Dont do it Dada. Please do not tell me you think Schaub/Dre are the best QB/WR duo in the league.

If the Texans announced today that they traded Schaub/Johnson for Manning/Wayne for one year only....you would be estatic. Not to mention that makes the Texans instant AFC contenders.

Numbers are there....not their fault Kubiak is their coach. Take the Texans jerseys off of them and visualize.

[BlakeJ]

Numbers are there....not their fault Kubiak is their coach. Take the Texans jerseys off of them and visualize.

I see an often injured QB and a top 3 WR.

I'll give you Dre over Wayne but not by alot

but Peyton is three galaxies away from Schaub.

If the Niners were in the playoffs and the NFL said we could swap A QB/WR combo for those games...im taking Peyton/Wayne over Dre/Schaub without a blink. Noway I trust Schaub in that scenario.

[JMSFan]

Dont do it Dada. Please do not tell me you think Schaub/Dre are the best QB/WR duo in the league.

If the Texans announced today that they traded Schaub/Johnson for Manning/Wayne for one year only....you would be estatic. Not to mention that makes the Texans instant AFC contenders.

If they traded for one year only, and they had to exist with the Texans rushing game and team defense, then Manning and Wayne dont see the field past 16 games.

[BlakeJ]

If they traded for one year only, and they had to exist with the Texans rushing game and team defense, then Manning and Wayne dont see the field past 16 games.

Rushing Yards

Texans - 1475 yards
Colts - 1294 yards (league worst)

Defensesive ppg allowed

Texans - 20.8
Colts - 19.2

Defensive Passing YPG allowed

Texans - 217.9
Colts - 212.7

Defensive Rushing YPG allowed

Texans - 106.9
Colts - 126.5

Defensive Total YPG allowed

Texans - 324.9
Colts - 339.2



So with basically the same team defensive performance and a lesser rushing offense, Peyton Manning and Reggie Wayne made the playoffs easily...probably could have been undefeated in the regular season...and went to the super bowl. :)

[SLC93]

???????????????????????

Schaub in 2009

Yards (1)
Passer Rtg (7)
Comp pctg (4)
TDs (5)
Ints (10) worst

Most importantly

Playoff games - 0


Schaub is good....but he isnt the best. Not even close. Probably not even top 5. I know I'd rather have these guys....

Peyton
Brady
Brees
Rivers
Rodgers
McNabb

I put him in the category with Romo, Roethlisberger, Eli, Flacco, Palmer. Good company.

I wouldn't, not yet. Let him get through a season without missing games. Let him have a winning season. Let him win a division title Let him make the playoffs. Let him win a play off game. Until then, it's all for naught and he's clearly behind that group.

[wolfpack4life]

Matt Schaub had the most passing yards in 09'..Andre Johnson had the most recieving yards in 09'. Need I say more?


Matt Schaub and Andre Johnson of the Houston Texans handsdown.:heli:

[Matthew 2000 Eagle]

Matt Schaub had the most passing yards in 09'..Andre Johnson had the most recieving yards in 09'. Need I say more?


Matt Schaub and Andre Johnson of the Houston Texans handsdown.:heli:

Yep! And, Romo led the NFC (3rd overall in NFL) in passing yards, was also top 5 in completion percentage, QB rating, turned the ball over the 2nd LEAST amount of times in the NFL overall out of all QBs. He did that while playing behind one of the worst offensive lines in the league and doing it while playing in one of the toughest divisions in all of football and yet, there are some who still says that he sucks.

Now you Texans fans know how I feel when putting up an argument for a QB that you feel is getting slighted.

[SLC93]

Yep! And, Romo led the NFC (3rd overall in NFL) in passing yards, was also top 5 in completion percentage, QB rating, turned the ball over the 2nd LEAST amount of times in the NFL overall out of all QBs. He did that while playing behind one of the worst offensive lines in the league and doing it while playing in one of the toughest divisions in all of football and yet, there are some who still says that he sucks.

Now you Texans fans know how I feel when putting up an argument for a QB that you feel is getting slighted.

And he's won division titles, been to the playoffs 3 times, won a playoff game and currently has one of the top 5 qb ratings in league history ....... Matt and I and in the same foxhole on this one.

[BlakeJ]

Matt Schaub had the most passing yards in 09'..Andre Johnson had the most recieving yards in 09'. Need I say more?


Matt Schaub and Andre Johnson of the Houston Texans handsdown.:heli:

Why no playoffs??? I know the answer...Im waiting for you guys to recognize it. :)

[chhspantherfan]

Tony Romo / Dez Bryant

[wolfpack4life]

Yep! And, Romo led the NFC (3rd overall in NFL) in passing yards, was also top 5 in completion percentage, QB rating, turned the ball over the 2nd LEAST amount of times in the NFL overall out of all QBs. He did that while playing behind one of the worst offensive lines in the league and doing it while playing in one of the toughest divisions in all of football and yet, there are some who still says that he sucks.

Now you Texans fans know how I feel when putting up an argument for a QB that you feel is getting slighted.
Well, I only say Romo sucks because I dispise the Arlington Cowboys. Why? I have no clue, Just the sight of them make me angry.

So how do I spend my NFL season? Following my one and only team, the Houston Texans.

[JMSFan]

I wouldn't, not yet. Let him get through a season without missing games. Let him have a winning season. Let him win a division title Let him make the playoffs. Let him win a play off game. Until then, it's all for naught and he's clearly behind that group.

They were 9-7 last season.

And sure, lets celebrate Romo's ONE career playoff win.

[SLC93]

Well, I only say Romo sucks because I dispise the Arlington Cowboys. Why? I have no clue, Just the sight of them make me angry.

So how do I spend my NFL season? Following my one and only team, the Houston Texans.

Understandable. I feel the same way about several teams throughout sports. I actually have no memory of choosing to love the Boys. It just is.

[SLC93]

They were 9-7 last season.

And sure, lets celebrate Romo's ONE career playoff win.

Schaub's best season as a starter = 9-7
Romo's worst season as a starter = 9-7

0 playoff appearances for Schaub in 3 seasons as the starter
3 playoff appearances for Romo in 4 seasons as the starter

0 division titles for Schaub
2 division titles for Romo

Schaub drafted in the 3rd round, 90th overall
Romo undrafted

I like Schaub, I really do. He has the potential to do be amazing for that franchise but I get so sick of all the Romo undersells and rip jobs. He's off to an incredible start to his career and he's doing it on the biggest stage in football, on the hottest seat.

[Matthew 2000 Eagle]

Well, I only say Romo sucks because I dispise the Arlington Cowboys. Why? I have no clue, Just the sight of them make me angry.

So how do I spend my NFL season? Following my one and only team, the Houston Texans.

Well, unlike most haters, atleast you can admit that this is the reason you say he sucks.:D Your feelings for the 'Boys are exactly how I feel about the Philadelphia Eagles so, it's all good.

But, as I said, now you know how I feel.

[Matthew 2000 Eagle]

And he's won division titles, been to the playoffs 3 times, won a playoff game and currently has one of the top 5 qb ratings in league history ....... Matt and I and in the same foxhole on this one.

I understand that Manning is a better QB than Romo but, what I don't understand, is that it took him about the same time to win a playoff game than it did Romo. Yet, there were still a lot of people claiming him to be the greatest ever before he won a playoff game. It also took him 10 years to win his first Super Bowl.

People will throw up the argument of Romo having T.O. and Witten, with Crayton in '07. Well, we can throw up the argument that Manning had Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne and Dallas Clark for a few good years.

IMO;

Harrison>T.O.
Wayne>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Crayton
Witten and Clark are a draw, with Witten being a better blocker but, Clark being a better athlete.

[JMSFan]

Schaub's best season as a starter = 9-7
Romo's worst season as a starter = 9-7

0 playoff appearances for Schaub in 3 seasons as the starter
3 playoff appearances for Romo in 4 seasons as the starter

0 division titles for Schaub
2 division titles for Romo

Schaub drafted in the 3rd round, 90th overall
Romo undrafted

I like Schaub, I really do. He has the potential to do be amazing for that franchise but I get so sick of all the Romo undersells and rip jobs. He's off to an incredible start to his career and he's doing it on the biggest stage in football, on the hottest seat.

As good as Romo has performed at times, he has equally went south at times. Critical times (like the playoffs). Thats my knock on him, and I cant really place him on a pedestal above QB's like Schaub, Big Ben, Palmer, and even McNabb. For that matter, Dallas has been the only top seeded team in the playoffs to lose their 1st playoff game that year.
I find it funny that none of you will recognize the stats from last year about Schaub and Johnson, (they led the league, respectively) but then you back up your argument for Romo with stats.

[Matthew 2000 Eagle]

As good as Romo has performed at times, he has equally went south at times. Critical times (like the playoffs). Thats my knock on him, and I cant really place him on a pedestal above QB's like Schaub, Big Ben, Palmer, and even McNabb. For that matter, Dallas has been the only top seeded team in the playoffs to lose their 1st playoff game that year.
I find it funny that none of you will recognize the stats from last year about Schaub and Johnson, (they led the league, respectively) but then you back up your argument for Romo with stats.

Argument is understood but, you can actually count me in the minority that likes Schaub. Houston's TE Owen Daniels isn't a bad player himself!

[JMSFan]

Argument is understood but, you can actually count me in the minority that likes Schaub. Houston's TE Owen Daniels isn't a bad player himself!

Yea, Schaub is a solid QB, no doubt. You know, the division that the Texans play in is tough, and its gonna always be a challenge for them to get a div. title as long as Indy is there.

[Matthew 2000 Eagle]

Yea, Schaub is a solid QB, no doubt. You know, the division that the Texans play in is tough, and its gonna always be a challenge for them to get a div. title as long as Indy is there.

Very true! I can see Peyton putting up atleast 5 more great years but, that also depends on what the Colts offensive line is looking like over those years too.

The Texans also need to start playing some consistent defense. Get that under control, with Schaub and Johnson putting up those numbers, then they could be hell to deal with.

[SLC93]

As good as Romo has performed at times, he has equally went south at times. Critical times (like the playoffs). Thats my knock on him, and I cant really place him on a pedestal above QB's like Schaub, Big Ben, Palmer, and even McNabb. For that matter, Dallas has been the only top seeded team in the playoffs to lose their 1st playoff game that year.
I find it funny that none of you will recognize the stats from last year about Schaub and Johnson, (they led the league, respectively) but then you back up your argument for Romo with stats.

This is where the frustration comes for many Dallas fans. Romo played well against Seattle but botched a fg snap. He was nowhere near the reason they lost to NY and we all know the MInny loss was on the line play.

As far as 07 Dallas goes is there any shame in losing to a team that beat the top 3 seeded teams in that years playoffs, all on the road? And what about that team, the NY Giants, who managed to lose in 08 the exact same way Dallas did in 07 but it never gets mentioned?

Many of us do recognize those numbers. They were a tremendous duo, maybe best in the league. We kinda morphed the topic a bit and started talking qb rankings, though. Romo can and has put up those same numbers while winning more games and staying healthy. Back on point no duo is Dallas has done enough to merit mention in this debate. Austin and Romo just do not have the body of work to qualify and Dez hasn't caught a ball yet. At this point Schaub/Johnson are the present and future with Manning/Wayne holding the best longevity edge. Fitzgerald will be breaking in a new qb and wont have Boldin opposite him anymore. He'll still be a beast but those are factors that I think remove him from the equation for now.

[BlakeJ]

None of the above are Manning/Wayne worthy. Andre Johnson makes the Schaub/Johnson duo. Schaub has posted one winning year and 1 year of 4,000+ yards and suddenly he is more valuable than Manning.

I was waiting for someone to recognize why Houston lost more games than Indy last year despite having a better run game and same production on defense but everyone is busy homering it up.

Guess who is first in the league in passing 3rd down %?? Noone moves the chains and keeps drives alive like Peyton Manning. No QB in NFL history manages a football game every weekend like him.

Guess who was dead last in sacks allowed?? Indy was...and its not because they had a good OLine. Their Oline was horrific the last couple years. It is Peytons ability to read a defense, audible, and make a play early that saved them alot of sacks. Ryan Diem, Kyle DVan, Jeff Saturday, Mike Pollak, and Charlie Johnson were his starting linemen last year. Outside of Saturday who is old...that line is GARBAGE!

Guess who is at the top of the list in Red Zone percentage? Thats right...the Colts. Peyton rarely lets scoring opportunities go to waste.

In all Peyton Manning is more efficient way beyond passing yards stats than Romo or Schaub have been and will probably ever be. his football IQ is untouchable.

Andre Johnson > Reggie Wayne
Matt Schaub <<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Peyton Manning

[wolfpack4life]

None of the above are Manning/Wayne worthy. Andre Johnson makes the Schaub/Johnson duo. Schaub has posted one winning year and 1 year of 4,000+ yards and suddenly he is more valuable than Manning.

I was waiting for someone to recognize why Houston lost more games than Indy last year despite having a better run game and same production on defense but everyone is busy homering it up.

Guess who is first in the league in passing 3rd down %?? Noone moves the chains and keeps drives alive like Peyton Manning. No QB in NFL history manages a football game every weekend like him.

Guess who was dead last in sacks allowed?? Indy was...and its not because they had a good OLine. Their Oline was horrific the last couple years. It is Peytons ability to read a defense, audible, and make a play early that saved them alot of sacks. Ryan Diem, Kyle DVan, Jeff Saturday, Mike Pollak, and Charlie Johnson were his starting linemen last year. Outside of Saturday who is old...that line is GARBAGE!

Guess who is at the top of the list in Red Zone percentage? Thats right...the Colts. Peyton rarely lets scoring opportunities go to waste.

In all Peyton Manning is more efficient way beyond passing yards stats than Romo or Schaub have been and will probably ever be. his football IQ is untouchable.

Andre Johnson > Reggie Wayne
Matt Schaub <<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Peyton Manning
I agree on the Peyton Manning being better than Matt Scaub.

But you have to put the Schaub/Johnson duo over the Peyton/Reggie duo. Andre Johnson just out does Reggie Wayne by a mile IMO.

Good comparisons though. It's no wonder that the Indy/Houston game is always close.

[BlakeJ]

I agree on the Peyton Manning being better than Matt Scaub.

But you have to put the Schaub/Johnson duo over the Peyton/Reggie duo. Andre Johnson just out does Reggie Wayne by a mile IMO.

Good comparisons though. It's no wonder that the Indy/Houston game is always close.

:eek:

Put the kool aid down.

[BlakeJ]

I agree on the Peyton Manning being better than Matt Scaub.

But you have to put the Schaub/Johnson duo over the Peyton/Reggie duo. Andre Johnson just out does Reggie Wayne by a mile IMO.

Good comparisons though. It's no wonder that the Indy/Houston game is always close.

One more thing....production wise....Andre Johnson hasnt been that much better than Reggie Wayne.

2003-04

Dre - 66 for 976 4 TDs
Reggie - 68 for 838 7 TDs

2004-05

Dre - 79 for 1142 6 TDs
Reggie - 77 for 1210 12 TDs

2005-06

Dre - 63 for 688 2 TDs
Reggie - 83 for 1055 5 TDs

2006-07

Dre - 103 for 1147 5 TDs
Reggie - 86 for 1310 9 TDs

2007-08

Dre - 60 for 851 8 TDs
Reggie - 104 for 1510 10 TDs

2008-09

Dre - 115 for 1575 8 TDs
Reggie - 82 for 1145 6TDs

2009-10

Dre - 101 for 1569 9 TDs
Reggie - 100 for 1264 10 TDs

Right now Dre is better than Wayne, but not as much as you are leading him on to be.

The biggest stat for all parties involved is.......

Playoff Games played

Manning/Wayne - 15
Schaub/Dre - ZEROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Like I said...numbers dont tel the whole story. They complete story says Manning/Wayne in a land slide.

[F18mustang]

QB-F18
"WIDE" Receiver: BDB's Mom

[dada]

One more thing....production wise....Andre Johnson hasnt been that much better than Reggie Wayne.

2003-04

Dre - 66 for 976 4 TDs
Reggie - 68 for 838 7 TDs

2004-05

Dre - 79 for 1142 6 TDs
Reggie - 77 for 1210 12 TDs




2005-06

Dre - 63 for 688 2 TDs
Reggie - 83 for 1055 5 TDs

2006-07

Dre - 103 for 1147 5 TDs
Reggie - 86 for 1310 9 TDs

2007-08

Dre - 60 for 851 8 TDs
Reggie - 104 for 1510 10 TDs

2008-09

Dre - 115 for 1575 8 TDs
Reggie - 82 for 1145 6TDs

2009-10

Dre - 101 for 1569 9 TDs
Reggie - 100 for 1264 10 TDs

Right now Dre is better than Wayne, but not as much as you are leading him on to be.

The biggest stat for all parties involved is.......

Playoff Games played

Manning/Wayne - 15
Schaub/Dre - ZEROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Like I said...numbers dont tel the whole story. They complete story says Manning/Wayne in a land slide.

SO you're saying Wayne has played way more games than Dre(playoffs) and the numbers are almost even? Soo can we can imagine what Dre would do if he played more than 16 games per year? Are playoff yards included in these stats? Since the 03-04 season, Dre's rookie year, Marvin has played 16+ games every year since....Dre HASNT been to the playoffs, missed 3 games 05-06...and 7 games the 07-08 season.

Not counting games missed due to injury
every year listed the Texans played 16 games
Indy on the other hand
2003: 19
2004:18
2005:17
2006: 20
2007: 17
2008: 17
2009 19

[BlakeJ]

SO you're saying Wayne has played way more games than Dre(playoffs) and the numbers are almost even? Soo can we can imagine what Dre would do if he played more than 16 games per year? Are playoff yards included in these stats? Since the 03-04 season, Dre's rookie year, Marvin has played 16+ games every year since....Dre HASNT been to the playoffs, missed 3 games 05-06...and 7 games the 07-08 season.

Not counting games missed due to injury
every year listed the Texans played 16 games
Indy on the other hand
2003: 19
2004:18
2005:17
2006: 20
2007: 17
2008: 17
2009 19

All Reggie Wayne and Dre numbers I posted are regular season only. I didnt add the post season numbers from Wayne.

I would also say that Dre being a bit injury prone hurts his cause. Hard to be effective when you are sitting on the bench.

Wayne also posted those numbers in a majority of years where he was the #2 option behind Harrison.

[dada]

All Reggie Wayne and Dre numbers I posted are regular season only. I didnt add the post season numbers from Wayne.

I would also say that Dre being a bit injury prone hurts his cause. Hard to be effective when you are sitting on the bench.

Wayne also posted those numbers in a majority of years where he was the #2 option behind Harrison.

Dre played with David Carr........case closed.:D

[BlakeJ]

Dre played with David Carr........case closed.:D

I remember him...scrub...who does that loser play for nowadays anyhow?? :eek:

[Matthew 2000 Eagle]

I remember him...scrub...who does that loser play for nowadays anyhow?? :eek:

Last I heard, David and his white Mickey Mouse gloves were with the Giants.

[BlakeJ]

Last I heard, David and his white Mickey Mouse gloves were with the Giants.

He actually signed a free agent deal this summer with my 49ers. Thats right ladies and gents....The Niners now have 2 #1 pick QB's on their team with Alex Smith and David Carr. They need to go out and get Jamarcus Russell to complete the trifecta!

[Matthew 2000 Eagle]

He actually signed a free agent deal this summer with my 49ers. Thats right ladies and gents....The Niners now have 2 #1 pick QB's on their team with Alex Smith and David Carr. They need to go out and get Jamarcus Russell to complete the trifecta!

Truth be told, I don't even think David cares to be a starter anymore. Wish I could sit the bench and get rich like that. LOL!

I think Alex will actually end up doing okay! His work ethic will keep him around, much like Rich Gannon's did.

As for Jamarcus, hell! This dude eats on the sidelines!

[dada]

He actually signed a free agent deal this summer with my 49ers. Thats right ladies and gents....The Niners now have 2 #1 pick QB's on their team with Alex Smith and David Carr. They need to go out and get Jamarcus Russell to complete the trifecta!

Carr is back home now....wont see the field in San Fran....Trust me on this...He will end up coaching a High School in the valley or back at Fresno St. on the staff

[hshs]

I see an often injured QB and a top 3 WR.

I'll give you Dre over Wayne but not by alot

but Peyton is three galaxies away from Schaub.

If the Niners were in the playoffs and the NFL said we could swap A QB/WR combo for those games...im taking Peyton/Wayne over Dre/Schaub without a blink. Noway I trust Schaub in that scenario.

You are crazy on this one and you are trying to have it both ways.

If Manning is indeed 3 galaxies better than Schaub (and I won't disagree with that at all), then how much more impressive is what Johnson does compared to what Wayne does. Put Johnson with Manning and Wayne with Schaub and it might be more than 3 galaxies between them.

So I am fine with Manning/Wayne over Schaub/Johnson just because Manning is that good, but Wayne is nowhere close to Johnson these days.