PDA

View Full Version : Top 10 shakedown - week 8


twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 07:07 AM
1 chill
2 tjt
3 rrsp
4 allen
5 skyline
6 woodz
7 katy
8 hightower
9 et
10 gpns

11 slc / desoto

CuJo iS BaCk
10-17-2009, 08:47 AM
1 chill
2 tjt
3 rrsp
4 allen
5 skyline
6 woodz
7 katy
8 hightower
9 et
10 gpns

11 slc / desoto

R U serious!?! No one lost... so don't expect to see ant moves....
and Desoto definitely wont drop that far... Tyler Lee is a lot better than there record shows

If anybody moves in, it will be SLC

lil_cb_05
10-17-2009, 08:55 AM
Why is SLC dropping? Did they not play well?

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 09:23 AM
R U serious!?! No one lost... so don't expect to see ant moves....
and Desoto definitely wont drop that far... Tyler Lee is a lot better than there record shows

If anybody moves in, it will be SLC

Woodz dropped a couple of spots last week after a 14 pt win over College Park.

RRSP barely beat McNeil

Desoto almost lost to Tyler Lee who have been pretty terrible

SLC struggled against Marcus. They should drop down below GPNS who beat them.

Wins and Losses have not mattered a great deal in this poll.

the_phoenix612
10-17-2009, 10:03 AM
Woodz dropped a couple of spots last week after a 14 pt win over College Park.

RRSP barely beat McNeil

Desoto almost lost to Tyler Lee who have been pretty terrible

SLC struggled against Marcus. They should drop down below GPNS who beat them.

Wins and Losses have not mattered a great deal in this poll.
umm. What?

That game was never in question.

slcdragonfan
10-17-2009, 10:12 AM
Woodz dropped a couple of spots last week after a 14 pt win over College Park.

RRSP barely beat McNeil

Desoto almost lost to Tyler Lee who have been pretty terrible

SLC struggled against Marcus. They should drop down below GPNS who beat them.

Wins and Losses have not mattered a great deal in this poll.

Were you fishing? SLC led by 14 after the first quarter, led the whole game, had a TD called back near the end, and ran out the clock rather than score again. It was a great game, and Marcus is a good team, but we were in control, unlike CHILL who got behind against Duncanville by what, 14, and then took until the end of the 3rd to take control? I am just pointing out that your choice of words here are questionable. But rank us where you want, that is fine. GPNS with 2 losses ahead of us, fine. They are a very good team, and would be great with a passing game and no fumbles/penalties.

dragonsdaddy
10-17-2009, 10:15 AM
Woodz dropped a couple of spots last week after a 14 pt win over College Park.

RRSP barely beat McNeil

Desoto almost lost to Tyler Lee who have been pretty terrible

SLC struggled against Marcus. They should drop down below GPNS who beat them.

Wins and Losses have not mattered a great deal in this poll.

struggled to score every time they touched the ball save 1(not counting the kneel down final drive in which they had a td called back) we did struggle with time of possession which was a blowout win for fmm.

the_phoenix612
10-17-2009, 10:16 AM
struggled to score every time they touched the ball save 1(not counting the kneel down final drive in which they had a td called back) we did struggle with time of possession which was a blowout win for fmm.

Were you fishing? SLC led by 14 after the first quarter, led the whole game, had a TD called back near the end, and ran out the clock rather than score again. It was a great game, and Marcus is a good team, but we were in control, unlike CHILL who got behind against Duncanville by what, 14, and then took until the end of the 3rd to take control? I am just pointing out that your choice of words here are questionable. But rank us where you want, that is fine. GPNS with 2 losses ahead of us, fine. They are a very good team, and would be great with a passing game and no fumbles/penalties.
easy, guys. Wouldn't want to overwhelm him, now...

drgnbkr
10-17-2009, 10:51 AM
Woodz dropped a couple of spots last week after a 14 pt win over College Park.

RRSP barely beat McNeil

Desoto almost lost to Tyler Lee who have been pretty terrible

SLC struggled against Marcus. They should drop down below GPNS who beat them.

Wins and Losses have not mattered a great deal in this poll.

Carroll never even had to punt, the QB torched Marcus 24 of 26 passing-wise. Marcus is a solid running team who can win a playoff game or two if they start playing defense.

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 11:19 AM
easy, guys. Wouldn't want to overwhelm him, now...


Here are the teams I think should be ranked ahead of Carroll.

Teams 1-5. - self explanatory. But if you think Carroll should be in the top 5, good luck to you.

6. Woodz 7-0 and a win over Katy
7. Katy - only loss is to Woodz. beat NS who beat SLC convincingly.
8. Hightower - undefeated and the defending D1 runners up
9. ET - maybe you have a case here but they're becoming very consistent and your defense will be suspect against them. And they will defend you very well.
10. NS - outmuscled you overall and the score indicates that.

Yeah you scored 41 on FMM but their Secondary isn't very good from what I understand. You fail to mention that you also allowed 30. That's an 11 pt margin. Woodz was dropped after winning by 14 in a shutout against a team who scored 35 on undefeated Cinco Ranch. But go ahead and put your own ranking out there. Make SLC #1 if you wish. Nobody's stopping you.

dragonsdaddy
10-17-2009, 12:01 PM
Here are the teams I think should be ranked ahead of Carroll.

Teams 1-5. - self explanatory. But if you think Carroll should be in the top 5, good luck to you.

6. Woodz 7-0 and a win over Katy
7. Katy - only loss is to Woodz. beat NS who beat SLC convincingly.
8. Hightower - undefeated and the defending D1 runners up
9. ET - maybe you have a case here but they're becoming very consistent and your defense will be suspect against them. And they will defend you very well.
10. NS - outmuscled you overall and the score indicates that.

Yeah you scored 41 on FMM but their Secondary isn't very good from what I understand. You fail to mention that you also allowed 30. That's an 11 pt margin. Woodz was dropped after winning by 14 in a shutout against a team who scored 35 on undefeated Cinco Ranch. But go ahead and put your own ranking out there. Make SLC #1 if you wish. Nobody's stopping you.

i'm not disagreeing with the placement, just the argument that they struggled. had they tried to and scored the last, meaningless td, you would have unknowingly said they handled fmm.

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 12:10 PM
i'm not disagreeing with the placement, just the argument that they struggled. had they tried to and scored the last, meaningless td, you would have unknowingly said they handled fmm.

Woodz did it against us as well. Kneeled down at our endzone. But they were dropped based on a 14 pt win that was less than expected. 21 would have probably kept them in the good books. But all teams kneel with the game in hand. Except maybe Katy (eg. Bellevue).

KatyTigerDad0407
10-17-2009, 01:13 PM
RRSP barely beat McNeil
I really expected SP to be dominating their opponents. Are they really worthy of #1? Time will tell.

EagleMom
10-17-2009, 01:37 PM
Woodz dropped a couple of spots last week after a 14 pt win over College Park.

RRSP barely beat McNeil

Desoto almost lost to Tyler Lee who have been pretty terrible

SLC struggled against Marcus. They should drop down below GPNS who beat them.

Wins and Losses have not mattered a great deal in this poll.

DeSoto should not drop. Lee is better than what people think, and DeSoto had key players both on defense and offense out. Young players stepped up and still won the game. So DeSoto still has it, even with its all staters out!

platnmram
10-17-2009, 01:37 PM
I really expected SP to be dominating their opponents. Are they really worthy of #1? Time will tell.
This was the only close game.

SLC
10-17-2009, 01:45 PM
easy, guys. Wouldn't want to overwhelm him, now...


Not to worry, Cavdad is a hater and haters gonna hate.



As usual, he will be shot down by the 3 J's this week...lol.

dragonbuck
10-17-2009, 01:59 PM
DeSoto should not drop. Lee is better than what people think, and DeSoto had key players both on defense and offense out. Young players stepped up and still won the game. So DeSoto still has it, even with its all staters out!

Katy beat FMM by 10, Carroll beat them by 11 and ran the clock out in the red zone instead of scoring at will, which they had done all night. Did Katy struggle with FMM? Carroll was missing their #1 receiver, their D1 (Tulsa) outside linbacker that was Dallas area Defensive Player of the week last week, and their D1 (Miami) cornerback is out after knee surgery. Not to mention players that had just gotten back after being out with the flu.

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 02:01 PM
Not to worry, Cavdad is a hater and haters gonna hate.



As usual, he will be shot down by the 3 J's this week...lol.

So that's the best you can come up with? SLC is ranked where they are because I hate them and the Admins like shooting down my opinions?

Would you care to dispute the reasons why I think there's 10 teams who deserve to be ranked higher?

Didn't think so. The Coppell argument didn't quite work last week.

Trinity Alum
10-17-2009, 02:01 PM
1 chill
2 tjt
3 rrsp
4 allen
5 skyline
6 woodz
7 katy
8 hightower
9 et
10 gpns

11 slc / desoto

You can drop ET. Won't bother us any. :D

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 02:03 PM
Katy beat FMM by 10, Carroll beat them by 11 and ran the clock out in the red zone instead of scoring at will, which they had done all night. Did Katy struggle with FMM? Carroll was missing their #1 receiver, their D1 (Tulsa) outside linbacker that was Dallas area Defensive Player of the week last week, and their D1 (Miami) cornerback is out after knee surgery. Not to mention players that had just gotten back after being out with the flu.

On the flipside, Katy beat NS and Carroll lost to them by 13. What's your point?

SLC
10-17-2009, 02:07 PM
So that's the best you can come up with? SLC is ranked where they are because I hate them and the Admins like shooting down my opinions?

Would you care to dispute the reasons why I think there's 10 teams who deserve to be ranked higher?

Didn't think so. The Coppell argument didn't quite work last week.


Now now Cavdad...I could obviously disect your arguement, hasn't been hard in the past to do it, wouldn't be hard to do today.

We'll start with the Coppell arguement worked very well, as seen by the fact that the 3 J's KEPT them at #13 AND raised us up, so what do they know that you dont?


Better yet, what do you think you know they they don't...Come on, get real!!!

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 02:08 PM
I did have Lufkin in my top 10 last week but not this week via a non blowout win over Conroe. I guess I hate them too.

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 02:13 PM
Now now Cavdad...I could obviously disect your arguement, hasn't been hard in the past to do it, wouldn't be hard to do today.

We'll start with the Coppell arguement worked very well, as seen by the fact that the 3 J's KEPT them at #13 AND raised us up, so what do they know that you dont?


Better yet, what do you think you know they they don't...Come on, get real!!!

I didn't necessarily agree with the admin's assessment of Coppell last week. I looked at the wins prior to the Carroll game. Nothing mind blowing. This week they beat a disappointing Hebron team 38-32. Maybe it's just me but that 13th spot is going cheap these days. Particularly with undefeated teams like Cinco Ranch in the 20's.

SLC
10-17-2009, 02:20 PM
I didn't necessarily agree with the admin's assessment of Coppell last week. I looked at the wins prior to the Carroll game. Nothing mind blowing. This week they beat a disappointing Hebron team 38-32. Maybe it's just me but that 13th spot is going cheap these days. Particularly with undefeated teams like Cinco Ranch in the 20's.


I would think Coppell would be moving down some and Cinco moving up some.



That game last night between Coppell and Hebron had some varying elements to it, so some consideration make be taken into account for that, not sure though.

katy2007dad
10-17-2009, 02:47 PM
Woodz did it against us as well. Kneeled down at our endzone. But they were dropped based on a 14 pt win that was less than expected. 21 would have probably kept them in the good books. But all teams kneel with the game in hand. Except maybe Katy (eg. Bellevue).

You demonstrate a superb (not!) knowledge of the game dufus. Katy is famous for running up the score, right? Get real!

You have managed to question SLC's team and jab at Katy's team all in one thread. Congratulations! I'll get a trophy ordered for College Park so you have something to show for your football program. :eek:

Seirously, man, tone it down and keep it civil. No one has done anything to you.:confused:

dragonsdaddy
10-17-2009, 03:00 PM
i am uncertain why anyone read's cavdad's lists anyway. i feel less smart for having responded to them at all. won't happen again.

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 03:02 PM
You demonstrate a superb (not!) knowledge of the game dufus. No need to get personal. Katy is famous for running up the score, right? Get real!

Never said they were. They did punch it in when they could have taken a knee against Bellevue. Yes or No? No problem with it. They can do what they want if Bellevue can't stop them.

You have managed to question SLC's team we're discussing rankings. it happens. stop sucking up to them and implying you're brothers under the skin. and jab at Katy's team all in one thread. Congratulations! I'll get a trophy ordered for College Park so you have something to show for your football program. :eek: No thank you. We're ok with what we've done overall in our 4th year. Anyway, I'll still be proud of our kids even with an 0-10 record.

Seirously, man, tone it down and keep it civil. No one has done anything to you.:confused: I was. You're the one with the belligerent tone.

^^^

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 03:07 PM
i am uncertain why anyone read's cavdad's lists anyway. i feel less smart for having responded to them at all. won't happen again.

I had Carroll ranked 2 not long ago. Makes Carroll sense. You take them down a notch and it's automatically dumb. (or less smart)

Dragoneer
10-17-2009, 03:19 PM
TWCPfan1, I am amazed with you. Your opinion is currently foolish!! :mad:

You also have the rare ability to here peoples tone through the computer.
HAHAHA Why don't you get your posts approved by an 8 year old girl before you post dumb stuff cause they might know more than you!:Censor:

Dragoneer
10-17-2009, 03:22 PM
You also like to act like you were at every game and watched every game in the state so if you know anything about the GP SLC game you would know that our QB definately did not perform to his normal standards or stats. I want to see them again

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 03:25 PM
You also like to act like you were at every game and watched every game in the state so if you know anything about the GP SLC game you would know that our QB definately did not perform to his normal standards or stats. I want to see them again

Yep and every ranking out there is put out by guys who watched all 25 teams that Friday.

If you feel you can come up with a better top 10, please post it. I'm curious what others think the rankings should look like. It would be better than just crying about it.

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 03:27 PM
TWCPfan1, I am amazed with you. Your opinion is currently foolish!! :mad:

You also have the rare ability to here peoples tone through the computer.
HAHAHA Why don't you get your posts approved by an 8 year old girl before you post dumb stuff cause they might know more than you!:Censor:

I'm pretty sure I could spell 'hear' at 8. But whatever man....

the_phoenix612
10-17-2009, 03:32 PM
I'm pretty sure I could spell 'hear' at 8. But whatever man....
When did you learn about not beginning sentences with conjunctions?

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 03:35 PM
When did you learn about not beginning sentences with conjunctions?

Ok, let's start dissecting message board colloquialisms. Are you Carroll people really that sensitive??? Really?? You're this butt hurt over not being declared as great???

EagleMom
10-17-2009, 03:50 PM
Katy beat FMM by 10, Carroll beat them by 11 and ran the clock out in the red zone instead of scoring at will, which they had done all night. Did Katy struggle with FMM? Carroll was missing their #1 receiver, their D1 (Tulsa) outside linbacker that was Dallas area Defensive Player of the week last week, and their D1 (Miami) cornerback is out after knee surgery. Not to mention players that had just gotten back after being out with the flu.


I'm proud of them, they stepped up their game with key players out. I don't think I stated Katy or Carroll wasn't a top ranked team! DeSoto also stepped it up, with D1 players out and kids with the flu, and still won. All three teams listed above still worthy of being in the top 15. "The whole point, is key players were out, and they still had enough 2nd & 3rd string players to come in and win the game!" Anyway we take one game at a time, and a WIN is a WIN no matter how you got it!;)

Southlake Carroll Dragons
10-17-2009, 04:02 PM
The Carroll Football team doesnt care about getting ranked!!!!! I can tell you that the carroll's football team goal is to win district first thats all in their mind. Then carroll will bleach the hair and bring out the black pants and will do their very best to whomever plays us in the playoffs. All that matters is winning everygame from now on.

Southlake Carroll Dragons
10-17-2009, 04:05 PM
Ok, let's start dissecting message board colloquialisms. Are you Carroll people really that sensitive??? Really?? You're this butt hurt over not being declared as great???

Yeah the Carroll Football team will show you they are great in 9 weeks from now.:)

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 04:07 PM
The Carroll Football team doesnt care about getting ranked!!!!! I can tell you that the carroll's football team goal is to win district first thats all in their mind. Then carroll will bleach the hair and bring out the black pants and will do their very best to whomever plays us in the playoffs. All that matters is winning everygame from now on.

Yes. All that matters is the next game. Rankings and discussions about it is just for fan entertainment. Nothing more.

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 04:08 PM
Yeah the Carroll Football team will show you they are great in 9 weeks from now.:)

Ok.

txhsfootballfan
10-17-2009, 05:20 PM
twcpfan1....you are a real piece of work......

katy2007dad
10-17-2009, 05:25 PM
^^^

You sure told me Woodlands College Park guy. I feel empty.:p

Sorry all SLC fans, I tried but he has me figured out. I'm just another Katy fan that sucks up to SLC. It didn't have anything to do with garbage he was spewing about Katy earlier in the thread.:cool:

twcpfan1
10-17-2009, 05:30 PM
You sure told me Woodlands College Park guy. I feel empty.:p

Sorry all SLC fans, I tried but he has me figured out. I'm just another Katy fan that sucks up to SLC. It didn't have anything to do with garbage he was spewing about Katy earlier in the thread.:cool:

No interest in fighting, but if you'd like to give me your thoughts on this week's top 10, that would be good.

cougmantx
10-17-2009, 06:06 PM
Katy won't move up because of the district they play in but the team is starting to come togather...passing game is getting better each game...few more games and they are in the playoffs. Katy will peak at just the right time for the three peat. First time since the beginning of the season I have started to feel better about this team...watch out D2.

Of course Katy's so, so, is most teams great games...:D

Oh, by the way, if Morris gets the ball nobody can catch him...the kid is fast and DY hasn't even started back yet...hahahaha, love it!

allendad
10-17-2009, 06:20 PM
You Carroll people . . . .

QUIT YOUR CRYIN' ! ! !

You K N O W that game was
won by the refs ! ! ! ! !

;)



The real poll isn't a real poll
after all . . . . .

It will state . . . 5A-DII Champions!

Y'all and CHill can fight that one out.:D



.

LPack007
10-17-2009, 06:46 PM
Imo...

1 Cedar Hill
2 John Tyler
3 RRSP
4 Allen
5 D. Skyline
6 Southlake Carroll
7 TWHS
8 Desoto
9 Katy
10 Euless Trinity

the_phoenix612
10-17-2009, 07:27 PM
imo...

1 cedar hill
2 john tyler
3 rrsp
4 allen
5 d. Skyline
6 southlake carroll
7 twhs
8 desoto
9 katy
10 euless trinity
HOW DARE YOU RANK SLC ABOVE TWHS!?!?!?!?!

Dont you know the woodlands are the best team evar1!1!!!11?!??/?!?!?!1/!?1??!?

KatyTigerDad0407
10-17-2009, 08:29 PM
This thread went in the toilet fast. Here's my top 5 -

Cedar Hill

Tyler John Tyler

Skyline

Stony Point

TWHS

None have lost a game and that's the order they should be in. JMO

The Wood
10-17-2009, 09:12 PM
This thread went in the toilet fast. Here's my top 5 -

Cedar Hill

Tyler John Tyler

Skyline

Stony Point

TWHS

None have lost a game and that's the order they should be in. JMO
Sounds like logic to me...maybe not the exact order, but it doesn't matter. But if it did matter, your logic is fine with me...and TWHS at 5, 10 or 15 is cool.

The Wood
10-17-2009, 09:15 PM
Imo...

1 Cedar Hill
2 John Tyler
3 RRSP
4 Allen
5 D. Skyline
6 Southlake Carroll
7 TWHS
8 Desoto
9 Katy
10 Euless Trinity

LPack, I do have a question about 6-7 (just for discussion). If Katy beats NS, and NS beats SLC, and TWHS beats Katy...how would SLC be ahead of TWHS?

Shamu85
10-17-2009, 09:47 PM
When did you learn about not beginning sentences with conjunctions?

Don't you mean contractions? If you mean conjunctions, that would sort of make your post not make much sense, but that's ok if that's what you meant.

My top 5.

Harlingen
EP Coronado
Sharyland
SA Clark
Skyline

:eek::D:D:D:eek:

Edit; Actually my top 5 would look like this.
1. Lake Travis
2. SP
3. TJT
4. TW
5. Skyline

Eagle2
10-17-2009, 09:50 PM
imo top ten:

1. Rrsp
2. Chill
3. Jtyler
4. Skyline
5. Allen
6. The woodlands
7. Desoto
8. Slc
9. San antonio
10. Katy
:)

sTp2005
10-17-2009, 09:52 PM
Don't you mean contractions? If you mean conjunctions, that would sort of make your post not make much sense, but that's ok if that's what you meant.

My top 5.

Harlingen
EP Coronado
Sharyland
SA Clark
Skyline

:eek::D:D:eek:

Sounds good to me! :D

drgnbkr
10-17-2009, 10:38 PM
imo top ten:

1. Rrsp
2. Chill
3. Jtyler
4. Skyline
5. Allen
6. The woodlands
7. Desoto
8. Slc
9. San antonio
10. Katy
:)


I like San Antonio at #9...just give us the whole city!:D

LPack007
10-17-2009, 10:51 PM
LPack, I do have a question about 6-7 (just for discussion). If Katy beats NS, and NS beats SLC, and TWHS beats Katy...how would SLC be ahead of TWHS?

It's not my top ten, this is what I thought the Kt's would have as a top ten..

texalaska
10-17-2009, 10:58 PM
(1) Cedar - no losses – 3 good teams – 2 ranked top 10
(2) Tyler John Tyler - no losses – 3 good teams – 2 ranked between 11-17
(3) Woodlands - no losses – decent schedule – 2 wins over 2 good teams – 1 ranked in top 10
(4) Skyline - no losses – 3 decent wins – no ranked teams
(5) Stony Pt - no losses – 1 decent win – no ranked teams – should have won last gm by more than 7 pts - has played weak teams
(6) Katy – One loss to top 10 ranked team – strong schedule pre district - Played 4 really good teams – 4 rated – 2 rated top 10 & 12
(7) Allen – one loss to 4a team – win over trinity
(8) Desoto - one loss to top 10 team – win over two more good teams – should have won last game by more than 7 pts
(9) SLC - one loss to rated team – one win over good team FFM - remaining teams weak
(10) Trinity - two losses to two top 10 ranked teams

Champion
10-17-2009, 11:34 PM
(1) Cedar - no losses – 3 good teams – 2 ranked top 10
(2) Tyler John Tyler - no losses – 3 good teams – 2 ranked between 11-17
(3) Woodlands - no losses – decent schedule – 2 wins over 2 good teams – 1 ranked in top 10
(4) Skyline - no losses – 3 decent wins – no ranked teams
(5) Stony Pt - no losses – 1 decent win – no ranked teams – should have won last gm by more than 7 pts - has played weak teams
(6) Katy – One loss to top 10 ranked team – strong schedule pre district - Played 4 really good teams – 4 rated – 2 rated top 10 & 12
(7) Allen – one loss to 4a team – win over trinity
(8) Desoto - one loss to top 10 team – win over two more good teams – should have won last game by more than 7 pts
(9) SLC - one loss to rated team – one win over good team FFM - remaining teams weak
(10) Trinity - two losses to two top 10 ranked teams

This order seems very logical to me. A debate could be North Shore below SLC? Can't say that SLC is better than NS even if NS has two losses. Other than NS, SLC hasn't played any real tough teams. The Marcus game was a closer game than the others. Marcus is so one dimensional though. It can beat some teams that have weak offenses. It has a powerful running game. One thing SLC doesn't do is run up scores so the margins of victory are sometimes understated.

CuJo iS BaCk
10-17-2009, 11:35 PM
(1) Cedar - no losses – 3 good teams – 2 ranked top 10
(2) Tyler John Tyler - no losses – 3 good teams – 2 ranked between 11-17
(3) Woodlands - no losses – decent schedule – 2 wins over 2 good teams – 1 ranked in top 10
(4) Skyline - no losses – 3 decent wins – no ranked teams
(5) Stony Pt - no losses – 1 decent win – no ranked teams – should have won last gm by more than 7 pts - has played weak teams
(6) Katy – One loss to top 10 ranked team – strong schedule pre district - Played 4 really good teams – 4 rated – 2 rated top 10 & 12
(7) Allen – one loss to 4a team – win over trinity
(8) Desoto - one loss to top 10 team – win over two more good teams – should have won last game by more than 7 pts
(9) SLC - one loss to rated team – one win over good team FFM - remaining teams weak
(10) Trinity - two losses to two top 10 ranked teams


Good Reasoning....
Hard to argue with the top 5
:notworthy:notworthy

SLC
10-17-2009, 11:54 PM
(1) Cedar - no losses – 3 good teams – 2 ranked top 10
(2) Tyler John Tyler - no losses – 3 good teams – 2 ranked between 11-17
(3) Woodlands - no losses – decent schedule – 2 wins over 2 good teams – 1 ranked in top 10
(4) Skyline - no losses – 3 decent wins – no ranked teams
(5) Stony Pt - no losses – 1 decent win – no ranked teams – should have won last gm by more than 7 pts - has played weak teams
(6) Katy – One loss to top 10 ranked team – strong schedule pre district - Played 4 really good teams – 4 rated – 2 rated top 10 & 12
(7) Allen – one loss to 4a team – win over trinity
(8) Desoto - one loss to top 10 team – win over two more good teams – should have won last game by more than 7 pts
(9) SLC - one loss to rated team – 2 wins over 2 ranked teams #13 and #23
(10) Trinity - two losses to two top 10 ranked teams

fify.

slcdragonfan
10-18-2009, 01:01 AM
Ok, let's start dissecting message board colloquialisms. Are you Carroll people really that sensitive??? Really?? You're this butt hurt over not being declared as great???

Personally, I didn't like the 'struggled' part. It was a good ball game, but IF YOU HAD SEEN IT OR KNEW ANYTHING ABOUT IT you would know that was the wrong word to use. That's about all I have to say about it because much more would come across as dissing an opponent I respect.

Rankings. Meh.....

slcdragonfan
10-18-2009, 01:04 AM
This thread went in the toilet fast. Here's my top 5 -

Cedar Hill

Tyler John Tyler

Skyline

Stony Point

TWHS

None have lost a game and that's the order they should be in. JMO

looks good to me....

btownfever
10-18-2009, 01:06 AM
Were you fishing? SLC led by 14 after the first quarter, led the whole game, had a TD called back near the end, and ran out the clock rather than score again. It was a great game, and Marcus is a good team, but we were in control, unlike CHILL who got behind against Duncanville by what, 14, and then took until the end of the 3rd to take control? I am just pointing out that your choice of words here are questionable. But rank us where you want, that is fine. GPNS with 2 losses ahead of us, fine. They are a very good team, and would be great with a passing game and no fumbles/penalties.

yeah CHill outscored d'ville 41-9 in the second half so we suck!

slcdragonfan
10-18-2009, 01:11 AM
yeah CHill outscored d'ville 41-9 in the second half so we suck!

That is NOT what I said, that is NOT what I meant, and I suspect you know that.

Try and stick with the POINT which was, he used the word 'struggled'. Not an appropriate word for our game. Did CHILL get behind in the D'ville game? Were they 'struggling' in the first quarter/half? I think the answer is YES.

Did CHILL kick in the afterburners and pretty much total D'ville by the end of the game? The answer is obviously yes.

I have give your team plenty of props so far, don't try to bill me as a hater.

btownfever
10-18-2009, 01:16 AM
That is NOT what I said, that is NOT what I meant, and I suspect you know that.

Try and stick with the POINT which was, he used the word 'struggled'. Not an appropriate word for our game. Did CHILL get behind in the D'ville game? Were they 'struggling' in the first quarter/half? I think the answer is YES.

Did CHILL kick in the afterburners and pretty much total D'ville by the end of the game? The answer is obviously yes.

I have give your team plenty of props so far, don't try to bill me as a hater.

ok ok you're not a hater....just win district so we can play in the regional final and all will be well...

slcdragonfan
10-18-2009, 01:20 AM
ok ok you're not a hater....just win district so we can play in the regional final and all will be well...

:D
Know what you mean...
The boys are doing what they have to do so far, yours as well. If that game happens, it will be like a state finals game.

Don't know why I didn't notice him before in the other games, but the RB besides Malena is mighty good. I like his style.

twcpfan1
10-18-2009, 06:24 AM
(1) Cedar - no losses – 3 good teams – 2 ranked top 10
(2) Tyler John Tyler - no losses – 3 good teams – 2 ranked between 11-17
(3) Woodlands - no losses – decent schedule – 2 wins over 2 good teams – 1 ranked in top 10
(4) Skyline - no losses – 3 decent wins – no ranked teams
(5) Stony Pt - no losses – 1 decent win – no ranked teams – should have won last gm by more than 7 pts - has played weak teams
(6) Katy – One loss to top 10 ranked team – strong schedule pre district - Played 4 really good teams – 4 rated – 2 rated top 10 & 12
(7) Allen – one loss to 4a team – win over trinity
(8) Desoto - one loss to top 10 team – win over two more good teams – should have won last game by more than 7 pts
(9) SLC - one loss to rated team – one win over good team FFM - remaining teams weak
(10) Trinity - two losses to two top 10 ranked teams

I like this list. I would probably slip GPNS in there somewhere around 9 or 10. Apart from that, good list.

I'm surprised nobody has Lufkin in their top 10. Only loss is on the road to top 2 or 3 ranked TJT. They have a strong case for the last 3 spots

platnmram
10-18-2009, 09:09 AM
(1) Cedar - no losses – 3 good teams – 2 ranked top 10
(2) Tyler John Tyler - no losses – 3 good teams – 2 ranked between 11-17
(3) Woodlands - no losses – decent schedule – 2 wins over 2 good teams – 1 ranked in top 10
(4) Skyline - no losses – 3 decent wins – no ranked teams
(5) Stony Pt - no losses – 1 decent win – no ranked teams – should have won last gm by more than 7 pts - has played weak teams
(6) Katy – One loss to top 10 ranked team – strong schedule pre district - Played 4 really good teams – 4 rated – 2 rated top 10 & 12
(7) Allen – one loss to 4a team – win over trinity
(8) Desoto - one loss to top 10 team – win over two more good teams – should have won last game by more than 7 pts
(9) SLC - one loss to rated team – one win over good team FFM - remaining teams weak
(10) Trinity - two losses to two top 10 ranked teams
Could you please explain the Woodlands ahead of sTp, Skyline, and Desoto? Honestly, without the same old line SOS. Most teams play the same district schedule every year until they get to the playoffs. How will they match up head to head? Rankings goes out the window when the playoffs start. Look what happened last year.;)

texalaska
10-18-2009, 09:18 AM
Could you please explain the Woodlands ahead of sTp, Skyline, and Desoto? Honestly, without the same old line SOS. Most teams play the same district schedule every year until they get to the playoffs. How will they match up head to head? Rankings goes out the window when the playoffs start. Look what happened last year.;)

Woodlands over Stony Pt because they beat a top ranked team and SP hasn't.

And Stony Pt should have won their last game against district opponent by more than 7 pts.

Woodlands over Skyline : same as above

Woodlands over Desoto: Desoto loss a game and Woodlands is undefeated.
And Desoto should have won their last game against district opponent by more than 7 pts.

Stony Pt has the worst sos of all top 10 teams.


Head to head and playoffs? Thats another thread.

I just analyzed the top 10 ranked teams and what they have done so far this season.

When it comes to playoffs - everything goes out the window.

Case in pt: 2008 Katy

Anybody can beat anybody on any given day. Plus some teams match up differently based on their schemes, strengths and weaknesses.

twcpfan1
10-18-2009, 09:54 AM
Woodlands over Stony Pt because they beat a top ranked team and SP hasn't.

And Stony Pt should have won their last game against district opponent by more than 7 pts.

Woodlands over Skyline : same as above

Woodlands over Desoto: Desoto loss a game and Woodlands is undefeated.
And Desoto should have won their last game against district opponent by more than 7 pts.

Stony Pt has the worst sos of all top 10 teams.


Head to head and playoffs? Thats another thread.

I just analyzed the top 10 ranked teams and what they have done so far this season.

When it comes to playoffs - everything goes out the window.

Case in pt: 2008 Katy

Anybody can beat anybody on any given day. Plus some teams match up differently based on their schemes, strengths and weaknesses.

I would have had STP above Woodz too. With both undefeated, all that's left is the head to head. I know it was last year but both teams seem to have come back strong this year.

texalaska
10-18-2009, 10:42 AM
I would have had STP above Woodz too. With both undefeated, all that's left is the head to head. I know it was last year but both teams seem to have come back strong this year.

Ok

But tell me who Stony Pt has beaten that is comparable to Katy?

{Katy because that is the highest rated team Woodlands has beat}

twcpfan1
10-18-2009, 10:48 AM
Ok

But tell me who Stony Pt has beaten that is comparable to Katy?

{Katy because that is the highest rated team Woodlands has beat}

None. You make a good argument. But the TWHS losses last year were to very fast and very athletic defenses like RRSP and Lufkin. So I guess I'm basing my argument on how 2 undefeated teams might match up against each other. But your SOS argument holds a lot of validity too.

EagleMom
10-18-2009, 11:37 AM
Woodlands over Stony Pt because they beat a top ranked team and SP hasn't.

And Stony Pt should have won their last game against district opponent by more than 7 pts.

Woodlands over Skyline : same as above

Woodlands over Desoto: Desoto loss a game and Woodlands is undefeated.
And Desoto should have won their last game against district opponent by more than 7 pts.

Stony Pt has the worst sos of all top 10 teams.

Head to head and playoffs? Thats another thread.

I just analyzed the top 10 ranked teams and what they have done so far this season.

When it comes to playoffs - everything goes out the window.

Case in pt: 2008 Katy

Anybody can beat anybody on any given day. Plus some teams match up differently based on their schemes, strengths and weaknesses.


Everyone is talking about who should have won by more points and etc... Dang #1 Florida just came back and beat an unranked team. So, I take it they aren't that good either? Like I said before a win is a win, forget stats, rankings, and etc... Skyline, CH, Stony Point, DeSoto, and TJT are 5 of the best teams around. But nothing really matters until they get on the field, and if they win by 1 point, it is still a WIN.

platnmram
10-18-2009, 12:13 PM
Woodlands over Stony Pt because they beat a top ranked team and SP hasn't.

And Stony Pt should have won their last game against district opponent by more than 7 pts.

Woodlands over Skyline : same as above

Woodlands over Desoto: Desoto loss a game and Woodlands is undefeated.
And Desoto should have won their last game against district opponent by more than 7 pts.

Stony Pt has the worst sos of all top 10 teams.


Head to head and playoffs? Thats another thread.

I just analyzed the top 10 ranked teams and what they have done so far this season.

When it comes to playoffs - everything goes out the window.

Case in pt: 2008 Katy

Anybody can beat anybody on any given day. Plus some teams match up differently based on their schemes, strengths and weaknesses.

A win is a win. Just ask the #1(Florida) ranked team in college right now. So I guess you should replace them with the #8 ranked team. Any good team is going to eventually have a tough game. Because any given day you can win or loose. So how do the Woodlands match up with sTp,Skyline,& Desoto? Analyze that.

dada
10-18-2009, 12:38 PM
LOL...the ones who keep saying "rankings don't matter" are the ones throwing a fit over someone's PERSONAL rankings.

I love HS Football:D

Good List Tex..."You GO Girl!!!!!!':D

platnmram
10-18-2009, 12:52 PM
LOL...the ones who keep saying "rankings don't matter" are the ones throwing a fit over someone's PERSONAL rankings.

I love HS Football:D

Good List Tex..."You GO Girl!!!!!!':D

Not really. My PERSONAL team started out last year ranked in the 20's and lost in the state semi-finals game. So really rankings dont matter. It's how well you play in the playoffs.