Carolina @ New York Giants

[BAMF cowboy]

Who wins?

The key to the game for Carolina is to shut down Tiki Barber (easier said than done). Put the game in young Eli's hands, who's making his first playoff appearance. After the Cowboys trounced Carolina on the ground with Julius Jones at Carolina, I don't think Carolina will be able to stop Tiki, and having home field advantage is the icing on the cake for this one. Giants win.

[Reaganrattler07]

I wanna see Carolina (and i voted for them) but I see New York winning. But yes, the key to stopping New York is stopping Tiki. Washington held Tiki to 84 yards(or around that) and they whipped'em 35-20.

[dragons08]

i want NYG to win, so the bears can play them, and then the bears beat the giants and i cna brag to yankeeman :D

[cougarcb16]

Washington never whipped us what you talking about. We would have beaten them but the refs took away a touchdown and a first down. My Giants will have fun with the Panthers. And its not just Tiki.

Dont forget ...
Burress and Shockey

[yankee]

Washington never whipped us what you talking about. We would have beaten them but the refs took away a touchdown and a first down. My Giants will have fun with the Panthers. And its not just Tiki.

Dont forget ...
Burress and Shockey
very good points. the giants are going to win this game. tiki needs to have to have an awesome game against carolina's tough d. eli also needs to step up, and get his completion pct. up. hopefully shockey will be healed for this game, since he didnt play against oakland due to an injury. if the giants hold steve smith to under 100 receiving yards, which wont be easy, the giants can definetly win.

[dragons08]

very good points. the giants are going to win this game. tiki needs to have to have an awesome game against carolina's tough d. eli also needs to step up, and get his completion pct. up. hopefully shockey will be healed for this game, since he didnt play against oakland due to an injury. if the giants hold steve smith to under 100 receiving yards, which wont be easy, the giants can definetly win.
i agree thats the key right there

[FootballJunkie]

Too much TIki in this one I think...but as quiet as kept little brother Ely has thrown for more yards than Peyton...if he keeps the int's down they have a good chance to make the NFC championship.

[Dragon20]

Steve Smith with rule this game
2 maybe 3 picks for Manning
Tiki still has over 100 yards on a lossing effort.

[Sacred Ground]

Have to go with the Giants in this one. They have a well balanced offense. The only thing to keep them from winning is themselves. The Giants rank 7th in penalties and are the most penalized team of all the playoff teams. The only thing working right for the Panthers at this point in the season is their special teams.

[Dragon20]

Steve Smith with rule this game
2 maybe 3 picks for Manning
Tiki still has over 100 yards on a lossing effort.


Man I'm good!!! Minus Tiki I was right all the way.

[FootballJunkie]

Yep Eli with 3 picks so far and Carolina has totally shut Tiki Barber down.
Carolina up 23-0 in the 4th. I would not have thought that.

[Slim-Rob]

23-0 final

[Sacred Ground]

I missed this pick by a mile. (now 1-2) Who would have thought the Panthers would come out clicking on all cylinders after finishing the season with question marks. That well balanced offense of the Giants was just plain flat. Gotta give credit to the Panther D though. Good luck to the panthers next weekend, their gonna need it.

[Dragon20]

I missed this pick by a mile. (now 1-2) Who would have thought the Panthers would come out clicking on all cylinders after finishing the season with question marks. That well balanced offense of the Giants was just plain flat. Gotta give credit to the Panther D though. Good luck to the panthers next weekend, their gonna need it.

ELI is not that good.

[FootballJunkie]

ELI is not that good.

Eli will be fine..had a real bad game. On the year he actually passed for more yards than his brother!!! On the downside he also threw more int's as well.

[yankee]

ELI is not that good.
people tend to forget that eli is only in his 2nd year as a starter and he didnt even start til halfway thru last season. he will be a very good qb in a few seasons.

[dragons08]

giants disappointed me i must say..

i went 2-0 on sat and 0-2 on sun..

lets hope its reverse next week b/c the bears play on sunday!!