Texas Heisman

[PurpleNation]

Just to take some pressure off of the playoff games for the fans. If you could select your Texas Heisman 5 finalist who would it be and who would you give your trophy to.

1. QB Greg McElroy, South Lake Carroll 244-372- 3,657 YDS 48 TD's 7 INT
2. QB Matthew Stafford, Highland Park 175-273 3,462 YDS 33 TD's 3 INT
3. ATH Sergio Kindle, Dallas Woodrow Wilson 218 Carries 2,298 40 TD's
4. WR Dez Bryant, Lufkin 41 Catches 950 YDS 14 TD's
5. RB Dimitri Nance, Euless Trinity 286 Carries 2,791 YDS 39 TD's


Greg McElroy gets my Texas Heisman Trophy.

[singularity]

What are the stats for those 5? More specifically McElroy and Stafford.

[c-town_scout]

What are the stats for those 5? More specifically McElroy and Stafford.

i dont know but i know that Stafford is alot better than McElroy

[singularity]

I won't nominate a QB that is one-dimensional. They have to be able to run and pass. Vince Young style

[PurpleNation]

I won't nominate a QB that is one-dimensional. They have to be able to run and pass. Vince Young style


Sorry there is not a QB that just sticks out to me that is that good. I know Sharrod Harris and Jevan Snead are UT bound, but I feel McElroy is the best overall player for a team in Texas.

[KatyTigerDad0407]

1) Lonny23-most knowledgeable
2) CyFallsMom-true fan,great spirit
3) dragons08-great kid with a lot of heart
4) StrakeDrake-passionate about his convictions
5) KT2000-good judge of character

5atexasfootball Heisman trophy goes to - CyFallsMom

[singularity]

I don't know one, or I would throw them out there. If there aren't any, McElroy it is then.

[berkner]

Just to take some pressure off of the playoff games for the fans. If you could select your Texas Heisman 5 finalist who would it be and who would you give your trophy to.

1. QB Greg McElroy, South Lake Carroll 244-372- 3,657 YDS 48 TD's 7 INT
2. QB Matthew Stafford, Highland Park
3. LB Sergio Kindle, Dallas Woodro Wilson
4. WR Dez Bryant, Lufkin 41 Catches 950 YDS 14 TD's
5. RB Dimitri Nance, Euless Trinity


Greg McElroy gets my Texas Heisman Trophy.



are u kidding me? if he wasnt on slc he would be nobody sergio gets my vote he carried woodro on his back

[singularity]

Probably, but the SLC system has molded him into an excellent leader on the field.

[PurpleNation]

are u kidding me? if he wasnt on slc he would be nobody sergio gets my vote he carried woodro on his back


I understand what your saying but it is real hard for a defensive player to win the Heisman. As good as Sergio was I feel that if Woodro Wilson would have had McElroy then they would have been better. But that is why I started this thread throw me your 5 that are out there. This is just a thought. Maybe KT2000 should actually have a board vot on this or something like that.


Plus the Competetion was God awfuly sorry what Kindle was going against.

[RGVBadBoy]

Bradly Stephens McAllen Memorial had 2,600yrds in 10 games....TEN GAMES!!!!!

[PurpleNation]

Bradly Stephens McAllen Memorial had 2,600yrds in 10 games....TEN GAMES!!!!!


I do know that he holds offers from Texas A&M and Iowa State so he must be doing something right. But the scariest thing about that stat is that he is only a JR. I think it is safe to say he will be atleast a 3 star recruit next season

[lonny23]

1) Lonny23-most knowledgeable
2) CyFallsMom-true fan,great spirit
3) dragons08-great kid with a lot of heart
4) StrakeDrake-passionate about his convictions
5) KT2000-good judge of character

5atexasfootball Heisman trophy goes to - CyFallsMom
What do I need to do to win next year or did Mom get the lifetime achievement award?:D

[TrojanHorse03]

Bradly Stephens McAllen Memorial had 2,600yrds in 10 games....TEN GAMES!!!!!

No he didn't, he had a shade under 2,300 yds, still impressive.

[TrojanHorse03]

I do know that he holds offers from Texas A&M and Iowa State so he must be doing something right. But the scariest thing about that stat is that he is only a JR. I think it is safe to say he will be atleast a 3 star recruit next season

By they way I put him down for at least a 4 star.

[TrojanHorse03]

I understand what your saying but it is real hard for a defensive player to win the Heisman. As good as Sergio was I feel that if Woodro Wilson would have had McElroy then they would have been better. But that is why I started this thread throw me your 5 that are out there. This is just a thought. Maybe KT2000 should actually have a board vot on this or something like that.


Plus the Competetion was God awfuly sorry what Kindle was going against.

McElroy would still be good if he didnt play for Southlake however he would NOT be in the discussion for high school Heisman. Straight up the only reason why 5A fans would even pay attention to Woodrow Wilson other than the fact that its the answer to the trivia question, which high school has produced 2 heisman winners, is Sergio Kindle.

[TrojanHorse03]

Just to take some pressure off of the playoff games for the fans. If you could select your Texas Heisman 5 finalist who would it be and who would you give your trophy to.

1. QB Greg McElroy, South Lake Carroll 244-372- 3,657 YDS 48 TD's 7 INT
2. QB Matthew Stafford, Highland Park 175-273 3,462 YDS 33 TD's 3 INT
3. ATH Sergio Kindle, Dallas Woodrow Wilson 218 Carries 2,298 40 TD's
4. WR Dez Bryant, Lufkin 41 Catches 950 YDS 14 TD's
5. RB Dimitri Nance, Euless Trinity 286 Carries 2,791 YDS 39 TD's


Greg McElroy gets my Texas Heisman Trophy.

The canidates are good they order is just wrong. I'll just say Dimitri Nance is at least ahead of Dez. And Stafford and Kindle are ahead of McElroy, and thats not a knock on McElroy at all. Its just if uve seem them play in person you know what I'm talking about.

[ACM Dad]

There were a lot of scouts checking out Highland Park last Saturday in Texslum Stadium. I hope they stayed to watch the 2nd game! :)

HP's QB looks like he's going to make some D1 college coach sleep very well at night. Is he committed yet?

Maybe we should start a 2006 Texas Heisman list. I've got a couple of potential candidates in the old ACM back yard.

[farmerfan]

There were a lot of scouts checking out Highland Park last Saturday in Texslum Stadium. I hope they stayed to watch the 2nd game! :)

HP's QB looks like he's going to make some D1 college coach sleep very well at night. Is he committed yet?

Maybe we should start a 2006 Texas Heisman list. I've got a couple of potential candidates in the old ACM back yard.


He is commited to Georgia, i am very jealous.

[ACM Dad]

I hate it when Texas talent leaves the Big 12. But, hey, the SEC has always been the premier conference in my opinion. Hard to argue with that choice. I sure miss the Southwest Conference. Those were the days.

[gritty52]

ACM Dad we finally agree on something!! SEC BABY!!!! :D

[StormingCowboy]

Sergio hands down!! In addition to 218 Carries 2,298 40 TD's, he's one of , if not the best, defensive player in Texas!!! he's definitely better at LB than RB.

[TIGER]

No he didn't, he had a shade under 2,300 yds, still impressive.


RGVBadboy is correct! Bradley Stephens had 2633 yds in 10 games. He reached the 2100 mark in his 8th game, Broke the valley regular season record in his 9th game with 2400+ yds and smashed the valley full season rushing record in his 10 game finishing with 2633 yds. He had three 300+ yd games in a row. He currently is on pace to be included as one of the all time top 10 career rushers for the state of Texas. He currently has 5400+ career yds according to a previous rivals post. check out his season stats on Texas THSCA.COM ( you need to type in the 5A classification and individual stat link )

http://coach.thsca.com/StandingsStats.asp?action=search&nav=Pressbox&menu=03&category=stats&type=off

[dragonsdaddy]

What do I need to do to win next year or did Mom get the lifetime achievement award?:D
she gets the vote on the theory that saying more with fewer words is the sign of true excellence. having calloused fingertips doesn't make one's imputs more valable. maybe lonny should win the lewis l'amore award, presented in a paperback edition.

[PurpleNation]

The canidates are good they order is just wrong. I'll just say Dimitri Nance is at least ahead of Dez. And Stafford and Kindle are ahead of McElroy, and thats not a knock on McElroy at all. Its just if uve seem them play in person you know what I'm talking about.


That sounds good to.

[CyFallsMom]

1) Lonny23-most knowledgeable
2) CyFallsMom-true fan,great spirit
3) dragons08-great kid with a lot of heart
4) StrakeDrake-passionate about his convictions
5) KT2000-good judge of character

5atexasfootball Heisman trophy goes to - CyFallsMom

My gosh Katy Tiger Dad - I am truly humbled. Lonny, how about we say it's a draw and you share with me? but then, there's dragon, Strake and KT2000 - I'm in this group with some of the great ones, the legends if you will!!

So where's the trophy - :D (j/k)

[Drake]

1)4) StrakeDrake-passionate about his convictionsOnly because I didn't do it!

[PurpleNation]

Only because I didn't do it!


LOL. But I say give it to Cy Falls mom

[lonny23]

she gets the vote on the theory that saying more with fewer words is the sign of true excellence. having calloused fingertips doesn't make one's imputs more valable. maybe lonny should win the lewis l'amore award, presented in a paperback edition.
I didn't know if I would elicit a response or not. Louis L'Amour didn't do too bad for himself!:D

How are those Owls doing? The headline said, "Kolb, Houston cook Rice to become bowl eligible.":D Go UH!:p

[lonny23]

My gosh Katy Tiger Dad - I am truly humbled. Lonny, how about we say it's a draw and you share with me? but then, there's dragon, Strake and KT2000 - I'm in this group with some of the great ones, the legends if you will!!

So where's the trophy - :D (j/k)
That's cool, but he cheated us. The 5 finalists are supposed to get wined and dined and a paid trip. I'm still stuck in cold Kyrgyzstan!:mad:

[implacable44]

I understand what your saying but it is real hard for a defensive player to win the Heisman. As good as Sergio was I feel that if Woodro Wilson would have had McElroy then they would have been better. But that is why I started this thread throw me your 5 that are out there. This is just a thought. Maybe KT2000 should actually have a board vot on this or something like that.


Plus the Competetion was God awfuly sorry what Kindle was going against.

compared to the elite programs Mcelroy threw against - I would say his success is as much a credit to his receivers as it is to him -

give me stafford or javon snead

[dragonsdaddy]

I didn't know if I would elicit a response or not. Louis L'Amour didn't do too bad for himself!:D

How are those Owls doing? The headline said, "Kolb, Houston cook Rice to become bowl eligible.":D Go UH!:p
that's why i pcked him instead of some hack. you do a pretty fair job, but finding the pearl amongst all the chaff is a beatdown.

saw where hatfield will retire today,too. like the man a lot, but he's been going thru the motions as a coach recently, it seems. my brother is trying to get them to go after dodge. i can hear the cheers across the state for rice's success in this hire.

[lonny23]

that's why i pcked him instead of some hack. you do a pretty fair job, but finding the pearl amongst all the chaff is a beatdown.

saw where hatfield will retire today,too. like the man a lot, but he's been going thru the motions as a coach recently, it seems. my brother is trying to get them to go after dodge. i can hear the cheers across the state for rice's success in this hire.
My dad wants Dodge to go to UT. I like Rice and just wanted to razz you about them.

I really don't think I have that much chaff. I think the vast majority of my posts are informative, entertaining, and insightful. That's not easy when you post as much as I do. I've pretty much stayed away from certain teams this year, including your's.

[dragonsdaddy]

My dad wants Dodge to go to UT. I like Rice and just wanted to razz you about them.

I really don't think I have that much chaff. I think the vast majority of my posts are informative, entertaining, and insightful. That's not easy when you post as much as I do. I've pretty much stayed away from certain teams this year, including your's.
you never came in to get your shoulder reduced, or maybe it's better to leave it dislocated for the self-flaggelation on the dorsal torso. hey, what's the high over there this week. dangit, it was almost 85 in the hill country this weekend. tough on the deer hunters.

[CyFallsMom]

That's cool, but he cheated us. The 5 finalists are supposed to get wined and dined and a paid trip. I'm still stuck in cold Kyrgyzstan!

Well, I HAVE been invited to the Katy tailgate party before Saturdays game - maybe that's my wining and dining. Guess you'll have to live vicariously through me for a day! Not sure if they are paying for my gas to Rice though;)

[Drake]

Well, I HAVE been invited to the Katy tailgate party before Saturdays game - maybe that's my wining and dining. Guess you'll have to live vicariously through me for a day! Not sure if they are paying for my gas to Rice though;)Don't go MOM! I went to one and came away with only ONE thought---> "How am I continually losing arguments to these people?" :D

[ktchamp97]

4. WR Dez Bryant, Lufkin 41 Catches 950 YDS 14 TD's

I love Dez, but...

I see your homer pick, and I call with one of my own (hey, I'm allowed one a year, right?)

WR Michael Fuda, Jr., Katy - 41 rec, 1,060 yds, 18 TD...in one less game.

It's really not a homer pick since his numbers are better across the board.

Anywhoo...

To the original question...the answer is Sergio Kindle, in a walk. He's an absolute terror on defense as well. He's got to be one of the Top 10 players in the entire nation.

[CyFallsMom]

Don't go MOM! I went to one and came away with only ONE thought---> "How am I continually losing arguments to these people?"

Now THAT'S funny!! They are a force aren't they? Fun to talk to though and very football crazy like myself.

[bullrock]

If you're looking for a team leader who wins by desire I would pick the QB from Cove. He may not have the stats that SLC and High Park Qb has, but he runs well, throws well and makes great decisions. He is a game changer. If there are any Cove fans on the board, please help me out here. I was very impressed with him when we played them. We were pretty much dominating them on both sides of the ball until he entered the game, injured I might add, and completely took control.

[football fanatic]

I have seen Stafford, Snead and McElroy play this year......

In my opinion the only reason Snead and Stafford have been more highly recruited then McElroy is that schools had a bunch of film on them from their junior year. Colleges go after the QB position first and all they can rely on is game film.

All three are super talented and each possess unique strengths.....I would take any of the three anyday and I predict all three will be huge success's at the next level....

I don't think anywhere in the country has produced this type of talent in the same year....North Texas should be proud...

[dragonfootballfan]

In Texas this year, Sergio Kindle is just head and shoulders above everybody else.

[farmerfan]

In Texas this year, Sergio Kindle is just head and shoulders above everybody else.


where you been man, seems that is has been forever since I have reade one of your post. I usually look forward to them because you say it straight forward. Glad to see you back posting.

[dragonfootballfan]

where you been man, seems that is has been forever since I have reade one of your post. I usually look forward to them because you say it straight forward. Glad to see you back posting.
I was out of town for Thanksgiving. I read a little bit of the posts, but there has been so much action, that I am just trying to catch up.

[farmerfan]

I was out of town for Thanksgiving. I read a little bit of the posts, but there has been so much action, that I am just trying to catch up.

well thank God the clown poising as a Plano fan got banned last week. you would have had a field day with them.

[dragonfootballfan]

well thank God the clown poising as a Plano fan got banned last week. you would have had a field day with them.
I am sorry I missed that, but there will probably be more guys to play around with in the coming weeks

[yankee]

i dont know but i know that Stafford is alot better than McElroy
i dont know about that. i dont know if stafford was a runner but mcelroy had over 500 yards in the reg. season and like 10 tds.

[dragonfootballfan]

i dont know about that. i dont know if stafford was a runner but mcelroy had over 500 yards in the reg. season and like 10 tds.
Stafford is just amazing this year. McElroy is good, but I don't even think that he was the best quarterback in the district.

[yankee]

Stafford is just amazing this year. McElroy is good, but I don't even think that he was the best quarterback in the district.
macelroy threw like almost 40 tds and 5 interceptions while throwing for nearly 3k yards. thats pretty good. i havent heard of stafford. apparently hes pretty good.

[dragonfootballfan]

macelroy threw like almost 40 tds and 5 interceptions while throwing for nearly 3k yards. thats pretty good. i havent heard of stafford. apparently hes pretty good.
it is not just stats that make a player good. If you saw a Highland Park game you would see how amazing the kid really is.

[singularity]

McElroy also has a fantastic line to hide behind.

[farmerfan]

macelroy threw like almost 40 tds and 5 interceptions while throwing for nearly 3k yards. thats pretty good. i havent heard of stafford. apparently hes pretty good.


Stafford is the number 1 pro style QB in the nation this year. He is a solid Georgia commit and will be starting for the Dawgs pretty quickly. He has quided HP to a great season and has a duel with another great QB this week in Jevin Sneed. Both teams are 13-0 and a shot at a state championship birth is at stake, it is right down the street from my apartment at UNT but I will be at Tx Stadium.